Hindu succession and coparcenary: the 2005 amendment and a grandson's claim
Why in news: A Supreme Court verdict reported on 12 November 2026 denied a grandson a Class I heir's claim to his grandfather's property while his father lives.

Coparcenary is the set of Mitakshara joint family members who jointly own ancestral property. Each gains an interest at birth. The Hindu Succession (Amendment) Act, 2005 made daughters coparceners on the same footing as sons. The Supreme Court has now held that a grandson is no Class I heir of his grandfather while his father lives.
Syllabus: GS2 · Constitution; Prelims · Polity & Governance; GS1 · Indian Society & Diversity
Why this matters for UPSC
GS2 polity and GS1 society cover personal law, women's property rights and the Hindu Succession Act, 1956. Prelims can ask Class I heirs and the 2005 amendment; Mains, gender equality in coparcenary.
In short
Hindu succession joins two older schools of Hindu law to the Hindu Succession Act, 1956, setting rights by birth in a joint family against individual statutory shares.
Codification and the 2005 amendment moved Hindu succession towards equal, individual shares; even application must let daughters gain while settled transfers stay secure.
Why it matters
A daughter born into a Mitakshara family now stands where her brother does. She holds an interest in ancestral property from birth and can press for her share, even if her father died before the law changed. Families that divided their land through a registered deed or a court decree before the cut-off keep that division, so settled arrangements are not reopened. A claim that the family split its land by word of mouth alone will not be believed. For a grandson, a share his father received on partition is the father's to keep or sell, and buyers can rely on that. The larger question is how personal law weighs family ownership against an individual's freedom to deal with what he owns.
Prelims pointers
- Dayabhaga governs Hindu families in West Bengal and Assam; Mitakshara governs the rest of India, and under it a son's interest in ancestral property arises at birth.
- Class I heirs of a male Hindu under the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 include his son, daughter, widow and mother; the son of a predeceased son is also one.
- Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 deals with interest in coparcenary property; Section 8 lays down how a male Hindu's property passes when he leaves no will.
- Under the original proviso, the notional partition only fixed a dead coparcener's share where a female Class I heir survived him; it did not break up the coparcenary.
- Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma (2020) overruled Prakash v. Phulavati (2016) and partly overruled Danamma v. Amar (2018) on daughters' coparcenary rights.
- The amended Section 6 saves any partition, alienation, disposition or will made before 20 December 2004 from a daughter's later claim.
- The 2005 amendment allots a predeceased son's or predeceased daughter's share to that child's surviving children.
Practise a UPSC-style question
With reference to the schools of Hindu law, consider the following statements:
1. The Mitakshara school governs Hindu joint families in West Bengal and Assam.
2. Under the Dayabhaga school, a son's right in family property opens only on his father's death.
3. Under the Mitakshara school, a son may claim a share in coparcenary property during his father's lifetime.
Which of the statements given above is/are correct?
- (a) 1 and 2 only
- (b) 2 and 3 only
- (c) 1 and 3 only
- (d) 1, 2 and 3
Show the answer
Answer: (b) 2 and 3 only
Answer: (b) 2 and 3 only. West Bengal and Assam follow Dayabhaga, not Mitakshara, so statement 1 fails.
Statement 1: incorrect. Dayabhaga is the school followed in West Bengal and Assam; Mitakshara applies in the rest of India.
Statement 2: correct. Under Dayabhaga the father owns the property outright, and the son's right begins only when the father dies.
Statement 3: correct. Under Mitakshara a son acquires an interest in ancestral coparcenary property at birth and can seek his share even while the father lives.
Eliminate: Statement 1 swaps the two schools' regions, so every option containing 1 goes. Out: (a), (c), (d).
Trap: Look-alike names. The two schools are swapped in statement 1, a confusion that is easy when both are learnt together.
Remember: Dayabhaga: West Bengal and Assam, right on father's death. Mitakshara: rest of India, right by birth.
More Explainers
- CDRI: India's coalition for disaster-resilient infrastructure Environment
- Pichwai painting of Nathdwara, Rajasthan National
- Kerch Strait: the sea link between the Black Sea and Azov World & IR
- Wind energy in India: potential, offshore wind and the policy push Economy
- Pallikaranai marsh: a Chennai Ramsar site and its zone of influence Environment
- Andaman cobra: India's only island cobra, Endangered and endemic Environment
- International Coconut Community and India's Coconut Development Board World & IR
- Real Estate (Regulation and Development) Act, 2016: how it protects homebuyers Polity
- Open correctional institutions and the Supreme Court's 2026 directions Polity
- ICTP, Trieste: the UNESCO-IAEA centre for physics and mathematics Sci-Tech
- PJ.2.1 and how new Covid variants are classified and tracked Sci-Tech
- Berlin Conference of 1884-85 and the rules for colonising Africa World & IR