Decode Civils CAShorts
ExplainerPolityGS2Prelims

Commissions on Centre-State relations: Sarkaria, Punchhi and States' own reviews

By CAShorts DeskPublished Sources: The Hindu; Inter-State Council Secretariat, Ministry of Home Affairs; Constitution of India (Legislative Department).

Why in news: Tamil Nadu disbanded its High-Level Committee on Union-State Relations, chaired by Justice Kurian Joseph, before its final report, as reported on 9 November 2026.

Commissions on Centre-State relations: Sarkaria, Punchhi and States' own reviews
Illustration (AI-generated)

Commissions on Centre-State relations review how powers, functions and finances are shared between the Union and the States. The Sarkaria Commission made 247 recommendations, including a permanent secretariat for an Inter-State Council; the Punchhi Commission made 273. Tamil Nadu has disbanded its own High-Level Committee on Union-State Relations, chaired by Justice Kurian Joseph.

Syllabus: GS2 · Constitution; GS2 · Federalism & Local Government; Prelims · Polity & Governance

Why this matters for UPSC

GS2 polity: Centre-State relations, Article 356 and the Inter-State Council under Article 263. Prelims asks what the commissions recommended; Mains asks how to balance federal power.

In short

The Constitution divides powers, functions and finances between the Union and the States; commissions on Centre-State relations review how that division works and propose changes.

Reviews of Centre-StaterelationsRajamannar CommitteeSarkaria CommissionPunchhi CommissionKurian Joseph Committee

The Sarkaria and Punchhi recommendations on Governors and Article 356 remain the tested agenda; acting on them would build more federal trust than new committees.

Why it matters

A family in any State elects a government expecting it to serve its full term. Whether the Union can set that government aside, and on what kind of report, decides whether that vote holds. The commissions on Centre-State relations tried to make such interventions rare and reasoned, and to give States a standing forum to settle disagreements with the Union before they turn into crises. Where that forum works, shared concerns such as river water and policing are settled by discussion. When a State ends its own review midway, the evidence it gathered may never reach that forum, and the national debate on federal balance loses one State's considered case.

Prelims pointers

  • Article 263 lets the President, by order, establish an Inter-State Council and define its duties, organisation and procedure.
  • Article 263 names three duties a Council may get: advising on disputes between States, investigating common-interest subjects, and recommending better coordination of policy.
  • Under Article 356, the President may assume the State government's functions and the Governor's powers, but not those of the State Legislature.
  • Under Article 356, the President may act on a Governor's report or otherwise when a State's government cannot be carried on under the Constitution.
  • Article 356(5) bars continuing a Proclamation beyond one year unless an Emergency is in operation and the Election Commission gives its certificate.
  • Sarkaria's terms asked it to respect the constitutional design protecting national unity and integrity; Punchhi's review also weighed court rulings on Union and State powers.

Practise a UPSC-style question

With reference to the Sarkaria Commission's recommendations on the Inter-State Council, consider the following statements:

1. The Council should inquire into and advise upon disputes that arise between States.

2. The Council should be charged with the duties in clauses (b) and (c) of Article 263.

3. The Council should have an independent permanent secretariat modelled on the Union Cabinet Secretariat.

Which of the statements given above is/are correct?

  1. (a) 1 and 2 only
  2. (b) 2 and 3 only
  3. (c) 1 and 3 only
  4. (d) 1, 2 and 3
Show the answer

Answer: (b) 2 and 3 only

Answer: (b) 2 and 3 only. Sarkaria kept dispute advice out of the Council's role but wanted wide duties and a permanent secretariat.

Statement 1: incorrect. The Sarkaria Commission said the Council should get no power to examine or advise on disputes between States.

Statement 2: correct. It wanted the Council's duties framed broadly to cover clauses (b) and (c) of Article 263: discussing common-interest subjects and recommending coordination.

Statement 3: correct. It held that without an independent permanent secretariat, staffed on the model of the Union Cabinet Secretariat, the Council could not earn credibility.

Eliminate: Statement 1 is incorrect, since Sarkaria excluded dispute advice. Out: (a), (c), (d).

Trap: Wrong scope. Article 263 itself allows a Council to advise on disputes between States, so a student may assume Sarkaria asked for that power too.

Remember: Sarkaria: Inter-State Council for clauses (b) and (c) of Article 263, not clause (a) disputes.

More Explainers

All Explainers

More Polity current affairs